Best Bets for Top 5 Picks in 2025 NFL Draft

Steve Starr
By , Updated on: Apr 9, 2025 12:00 AM
2025 nfl draft betting picks
  • What: 2025 NFL Draft Betting - Top 5 Picks
  • Where: Green Bay, Wisconsin, at Lambeau Field and the Titletown District
  • When: Thursday, April 24 to 26

The Tennessee Titans look set to make Cam Ward their new franchise quarterback with the Miami Hurricanes star a -5000 favorite be selected 1st overall. That leaves multi-positional superstar Travis Hunter, Penn State defensive end Abdul Carter and Colorado QB Shedeur Sanders up for grabs for the Browns and Giants at No. 2 and No. 3.

Let's look at the latest betting odds for the Top 5 picks in the 2025 NFL Draft. Odds are subject to change.

2nd Overall PickBovadaBetOnlineMyBookie
Travis Hunter (COL)-250-250-250
Abdul Carter (PSU)+185+185+185
Shedeur Sanders (COL)+1300+1300+1300

Boost Your NFL Draft Betting Picks

Before getting your wagers down on the 2025 NFL, don't forget to check out the latest 2025 NFL Draft betting odds to ensure you are getting the best bets available. Check the leading online sports betting sites reviews to make sure to shop around for the best promotions and lines when making your NFL Draft bets. And if you're new to the world of online sports betting, don't fret about being in over your head. There are plenty of how-to tips that you can peruse in our handy sports betting guide.

Travis Hunter heading to Cleveland?

The betting markets continue to move towards Travis Hunter (-250) landing in Cleveland following Colorado's Pro Day. The Heisman Trophy-winning wide receiver and cornerback has overtaken Abdul Carter (+185) in the past week. Once viewed as a possibility for the Browns at No. 2, Shedeur Sanders (+1300) could be sliding down the board with concerns mounting over his arm strength, attitude and tendency to pat the ball.

3rd Overall PickBovadaBetOnlineMyBookie
Abdul Carter (PSU)-180-180-180
Travis Hunter (COL)+250+250+250
Shedeur Sanders (COL)+400+400+400

Who's going No. 3 overall?

Will the Giants take Abdul Carter (-180) at No. 3? While the 21-year-old pass rusher is clearly the best talent on the board, he has a stress fracture in his right foot and did not participate in Penn State's Pro Day due to a nagging shoulder injury.

Shedeur Sanders (+400) could be poised to fall much further down the board, but Big Blue still has a dire need at QB after bringing in Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston. After all, the son of Deion Sanders showed off a pair of Giants-themed cleats prior to his final college game.

4th Overall PickBovadaBetOnlineMyBookie
Will Campbell (LSU)+125+125+125
Armand Membou (MIZZ)+330+330+330
Abdul Carter (PSU)+400+400+400
Travis Hunter (COL)+1000+1000+1000
Jalon Walker (UGA)+1000+1000+1000
Mason Graham (NMSU)+1200+1200+1200

Patriots to catch a break at No. 4?

The market is gaining confidence that short-armed LSU tackle Will Campbell (+125) will be the Patriots pick at No. 4 overall. Fellow offensive lineman Armand Membou (+330) is also seen as a sage choice to protect sophomore QB Drake Maye.

However, in this thought experiment, we're projecting Abdul Carter (+400) to land with Mike Vrabel in New England.

5th Overall PickBovadaBetOnlineMyBookie
Mason Graham (NMSU)-145-145-145
Armand Membou (MIZZ)+500+500+500
Jalon Walker (UGA)+900+900+900
Will Campbell (LSU)+1100+1100+1100
Tyler Warren (PSU)+1300+1300+1300
Ashton Jeanty (BSU)+1600+1600+1600
Tetairoa McMillan (ARI)+1700+1700+1700

Jaguars swing for the fences at five

Every mock draft in the nation has Michigan defensive tackle Mason Graham (-145) headed to Jacksonville at No. 5. However, new head coach Liam Coen was hired to put points on the board and turnaround Trevor Lawrence's career.

Looking at a weak wide receiver class, we think the Jaguars opt for offensive tackle Armand Membou (+500), or better yet, Boise State running back Ashton Jeanty (+1600).

Ashton Jeanty No. 5 Overall Pick
BetOnline
+1600

Meet the author

Steve Starr

Accomplished Sports Betting Specialist with over two decades of experience in sports analytics, strategic betting formulation, and risk management, with a particular focus on professional sports such as the NFL, NBA, and NHL. Proven success in applying statistical mo...

Online Sports Betting may receive compensation if you sign up through our links. Rest assured, we avoid biases and provide honest opinions on sportsbooks. Read our affiliate disclosure here.